RU EN
☰

Recipe · v1.3

Rye with scald and red malt

Rye-wheat · pan · scalded

A rye-wheat 80/20 bread with a scald and red fermented malt on a sourdough opara, no spices apart from optional coriander.

49 h 25 min Until bake ends
48 h 10 min Until bake starts
1 h 15 min Bake time
1 pan loaf (~850–900 g) Yield
Open worksheet
When to bake~2d to bake

Live timing needs JavaScript enabled.

Calculated for the current time; the worksheet lets you set any start.

Recipe

Current recipe

For baking now: the final working formula, ingredients, steps, and baking worksheet.

Taste & texture

A tightly closed, moist crumb — dense but not gummy — that slices clean after a full 24-hour rest. The short scald delivers moderate sweetness with a faint apple-like note that Stanley Ginsberg attributes specifically to red malt in the scald; the sourdough opara pulls in the other direction with a mild lactic tang. The crust is firm and dark, coloured by melanoidins from the fermented malt. Aroma is earthy and malty with a chocolaty undertone. The bread keeps well for three to four days, gaining flavour as the crumb sets.

As described by: The Rye Baker — On Scalds and Scalding (Stanley Ginsberg) , Beets and Bones — Russian Red Rye Malt Solod

Baking worksheet

Formula rye flour 400 g, wheat 100 g, water 380 g (76%), salt 9 g, red malt 15 g, coriander 4 g; scald 100 g rye + 150 g boiling water + 15 g malt; opara 100 g rye + 100 g water + 20 g active starter
Starter 3 refreshments: 5+10+10 → 5+15+15 → 5+20+20; 15–20 g reserve, 20 g active starter into the opara
Scald 100 g rye flour + 15 g malt + 150 g boiling water; steep covered for 1 hour, then cool to 35–40 °C before mixing
Opara 100 g rye flour + 100 g water + 20 g active starter; 10–14 hours at 24–27 °C to dome and a lactic smell
Mix opara + scald + salt + coriander + water + rye and wheat flour; K-beater on Min 1–2 minutes to uniform
Final proof 24–28 °C until rise of 1.5–1.8 times; reference 1.5–2.5 hours
Bake 250 °C 10 min with steam → 200 °C 30 min → 170 °C 30 min to 98–99 °C internal
Slice no earlier than 12 hours after baking, better 24 hours

Good to know

Why a scald in R1-C4 if there is none in R1-C1, R1-C2, and R1-C3?

The scald saccharifies part of the rye flour and brings out the sweetness; together with red malt it creates a recognizable scald rye profile. R1-C4 tests exactly how the scald works before adding molasses, sugar, and caraway in R2-C1 (Borodinsky).

Can I hold the scald at 65 °C for 3 hours as in Borodinsky?

Yes, but that is already R2-C1 technology: at 65 °C amylase is active and the scald saccharifies more. R1-C4 is simpler without thermostatting: boiling water in a thermos for 1 hour gives less sweetness but a more reproducible result for home conditions.

Can it be made without coriander?

Yes, coriander is optional. Without it the bread loses one flavor note, but the pair 'scald + malt + opara' remains the main lesson topic.

Why only 20% wheat flour?

20% of wheat flour gives a minimal wheat scaffold and slightly lightens the crumb, but does not turn the bread into a 60/40 rye-wheat. This lets you compare R1-C4 with R1-C3 (100% rye) and see what is changed by the scald and what by the wheat flour.

This is a rye-wheat 80/20 bread built on a scald and red fermented malt. The scald saccharifies part of the rye flour and brings out its natural sweetness, which then contrasts with the acidity of the sourdough opara to give a characteristic dark, scalded-rye profile — all without molasses, sugar, or caraway. It is the technical bridge between a plain 100% rye and a full Borodinsky.

How It Is Baked Around the World and Why

Scalded rye is the signature of the Northern and Eastern European baking belt — Russia, Latvia, Lithuania, Estonia, Finland, and parts of Germany — wherever rye grew better than wheat and bakers had to coax flavor and keeping quality out of a flour that has almost no gluten. The shared idea is simple: pour boiling water over part of the rye flour (a zavarka, German Brühstück) to gelatinize the starch and let amylase nibble it into sugar before the dough is ever mixed.

Why bakers do it. Rye starch gelatinizes at a lower temperature than wheat and is hungry for water; a scald binds that water into a gel, so the crumb stays moist and slices clean for days instead of drying out. The released sugars feed a slow, deep Maillard browning and give that faintly sweet, malty note people recognize as “dark rye.” Latvian rupjmaize and Lithuanian ruginė push the scald hard — long, warm saccharification near 63–65 °C for pronounced sweetness — while a simple Russian household scald like this one is short and mild. German Vollkornbrot leans on the same Brühstück for moisture but often skips the malt. Red fermented malt, used here, is the Russian fingerprint: it is the same ingredient that later defines Borodinsky, just used in a smaller, quieter dose.

Scald Theory

When rye flour and malt are poured with boiling water, two things happen:

  1. Starch gelatinization. Cold starch does not release water; hot rye starch in water forms a thick gel that holds moisture and makes the crumb juicier.
  2. Partial hydrolysis of starch to sugars. Amylase from rye malt (especially white fermented malt) breaks part of the starch into maltose and glucose. Red fermented malt has less enzymatic activity than white but gives more color and aroma.

This bread uses a short scald (1 hour in a thermos), without thermostatting at 65 °C. This gives moderate sweetness, clear dark color, and simplifies the home process.

Type of scaldTechnologyWhat it gives
Short in a thermos (this bread)Boiling water + 1 hourColor, moderate sweetness, simplicity
65 °C × 3 hours (Borodinsky)ThermostatMaximum sweetness, saccharification
No scaldNoneClean rye flavor of the starter

Why Cool The Scald To 35–40 °C

If a hot scald (above 45 °C) ends up in the mix, the acidity of the opara drops, and lactic acid bacteria suffer thermal shock. The dough becomes sluggish, the yeast slows down, and the flavor shifts toward bland and sweetish.

On the other hand, a scald that is too cold (below 25 °C) overcools the dough; fermentation slows and the proof drags on. The optimal range is 35–40 °C: warm but not hot.

The Scald + Opara Pair

The bread is built on the contrast of two prepared components:

ComponentWhat it carriesShare of flour
Sourdough oparaGas, acidity, rye background20%
Scald with maltSweetness, color, aroma, water binding20%
Final doughStructure, regulation of consistency60%

If the opara is weak, the crumb will be sweet-flat. If the scald is poorly cooled or made from old malt, the acidity of the opara will overpower the sweetness.

Why Only 20% Wheat Flour

20% of wheat flour gives a minimal wheat scaffold and slightly lightens the crumb, but does not turn the bread into a 60/40 rye-wheat. It keeps the loaf firmly in rye territory: the scald and malt stay the dominant flavors, while the wheat only adds a little lift and a slightly more sliceable crumb. It also points the recipe toward Borodinsky, where wheat flour sits around 15–20% and works together with the scald and molasses.

Optional Coriander

4 g of ground coriander is a flavor note, not a profile. In Borodinsky, caraway and coriander together with molasses create the recognizable spiced character; here coriander is optional and caraway is left out entirely, so the scald-and-malt pairing stays in focus.

If you make it without coriander, that is a fair variation, not a mistake — it simply lets you taste the scald and malt on their own and decide whether coriander belongs in this particular profile.

If Something Is Off

  • Scald pale and not sweet → the water was below 85 °C or the steep was too short; use full boiling water and keep it wrapped in a thermos for 40–60 minutes.
  • Mix killed the starter → the scald went in above 50 °C; check it with a thermometer and wait for 35–40 °C before mixing.
  • Crumb too sweet and gummy → too much red malt; 3% of the flour is the norm here, so reduce it or switch part to white malt.
  • Dark crumb but no malt flavor → unfermented (raw) malt was used; this bread needs fermented red malt specifically.
  • Crust burns before the crumb is baked → the malt accelerates browning; lower the start to 240 °C and cover the top with foil.
  • Acidity overpowers the malt → the opara over-matured; shorten it to about 10 hours or reduce the active starter.
  • Scald streaks through the crumb → it was not dispersed; mix with the K-beater for 2–3 minutes to full uniform.

Theory Sources

Ingredients

Change any amount — the rest rescale by the bread’s formula.

Component Grams Baker's %
Whole-grain rye flour g 80%
Strong white bread flour g 16.6%
Whole-grain wheat flour g 3.4%
Water g 76%
Salt g 1.8%
Red fermented rye malt g 3%
Ground coriander g 0.8%

Ingredient details

Whole-grain rye flour

Split
100 g into the scald, 100 g into the sourdough opara, and 200 g into the final dough
Brand
record the brand and grind before baking
Brand the author uses
MukaMuka whole-grain rye (mukamuka.ru)
Alternatives
Garnets whole-grain rye, Cherny Khleb rye

Strong white bread flour

Role
provides a minimal wheat structure in the final dough; do not use premium grade without recording as a deviation
Part of a substitute
together with 17 g of whole-grain wheat this replaces 100 g of first-grade flour, which the author cannot buy
Brand the author uses
MukaMuka Artisan Superiore 13.5% (type 00; mukamuka.ru)
Alternatives
any bread flour at 12–14% protein

Whole-grain wheat flour

Role
the second half of the first-grade substitute: it supplies the ash and bran particles a type 00 flour lacks
Why 5:1
First-grade flour differs from the highest grade not in strength but in ash: GOST 26574-2017, table 2, allows up to 0.75% against 0.55% and whiteness of at least 36 against 54 units; the gluten requirement is actually higher — at least 30% against 28%. Artisan Superiore is a type 00 flour, so its ash matches the highest grade. A 5:1 blend gives a calculated ash of about 0.74% assuming a typical 1.7% for whole-grain wheat; the real spread is 0.71–0.79% depending on the batch, with the GOST ceiling for wholemeal at 2.0%. On strength Superiore is not the weaker option: its 13.5% protein works out to roughly 34% wet gluten against the 30% minimum (an estimate using the usual factor of 2.5, not a measurement). The difference from mill-made first-grade flour is the grind: the bran particles in a blend are coarser.
Brand the author uses
MukaMuka whole-grain wheat (mukamuka.ru)
Alternatives
mill-made first-grade flour — then use 100 g of it alone instead of this pair

Water

Split
150 g boiling water into the scald, 100 g into the opara, 130 g into the final dough
Hydration
76%; the scald takes a significant share of water into the starch gel
Brand the author uses
Tap water through Barrier Iron x2 filter
Alternatives
any filtered or bottled drinking water

Salt

Important
if the salt is coarse, dissolve it in water or grind finer
Brand the author uses
Pink Himalayan salt
Alternatives
sea or table salt (avoid iodized)

Red fermented rye malt

Role
color, aroma, and sweetness; goes into the scald for full release
Substitution
without red malt, use 20 g of rye kvass concentrate, but record this as a deviation
Brand the author uses
Garnets red rye (fermented)
Alternatives
Bogatyr red rye malt

Ground coriander

Status
optional; in R1-C4 it adds a note without dominating; if omitted, record as a deviation
Brand the author uses
Whole coriander seeds, freshly ground in a coffee grinder
Alternatives
any brand of whole coriander

Conditions and equipment

Conditions

Place in the course
after R1-C3 (100% rye); the first lesson with a scald in the course before R2-C1 (Borodinsky)
Course block
scald, red malt, contrast of acidity and sweetness, optional spices
Doneness temperature
98–99 °C internal; probe thermometer required
Lesson closure condition
The lesson closes when the scald has given visible color and sweetness, the opara has given acidity, and the crumb has stabilized for 12+ hours.

Equipment

Pan
rectangular pan (Emile Henry Petit Moule Cake or similar in volume)
Mix
Kenwood KVC85.004SI, K-beater on Min; do not use the hook
Scald
thermos or a jar with a tight lid; temperature up to 90 °C will hold in a thermos for an hour without dropping below 70 °C
Oven
top-bottom heat; built-in oven steam at the start
Control
probe thermometer, scale, starting height mark of the dough

Nutrition: how to eat this bread

Bread nutrition facts

Per 100 g of bread

197 kcal

protein 5.9 g · fat 1.2 g · carbs 40 g

Per slice (50 g)

99 kcal

protein 3 g · fat 0.6 g · carbs 20 g

Automatic calculation from USDA + Skurikhin database for the baked loaf after evaporation. Numbers are approximate: 1) the database covers ingredients, not finished dough; 2) bake water loss is assumed at 10% — actual loss depends on crust, time, and pan. Add 5–10% in calorie trackers if needed.

Bread is a source of starch and energy. Its nutrition depends on flour, fermentation, salt, enrichment, serving size, and the rest of the plate.

Digestion
More whole grain, fibre, and fermentation usually mean longer satiety. White flour eaten alone is generally digested faster.
Helpful or harmful
Bread is not poison or medicine by itself. Overall diet matters; current guidance prioritizes whole grains, vegetables, fruits, and pulses.
Amount
For most learning tastings, 1–2 slices, about 30–80 g, is enough depending on loaf density.
Best pairings
Pair with protein, vegetables, and moderate fat; avoid making it a large standalone portion with sweet drinks or sweet spreads.

How to eat

  • Taste the bread plain for learning, then eat it as part of a balanced plate.
  • Slice dense rye thinner; with soft white bread, make sure softness does not automatically increase the serving.

Limits

  • Wheat and rye breads contain gluten.
  • For medical conditions, adjust bread type and serving size with a clinician or dietitian.
Sources

Instructions

  1. Prepare the starter

    Take the rye starter out of the fridge. Run 3 refreshments: 5+10+10 → 5+15+15 → 5+20+20; the final refreshment is small and should be used at peak.

  2. Make the scald

    100 g of rye flour and 15 g of red malt poured with 150 g of boiling water in a thermos or jar with a tight lid; steep 1 hour, then cool to 35–40 °C.

  3. Set aside the reserve and build the opara

    Before building the opara, set aside 15–20 g of active starter into a clean jar and put it in the fridge. Mix 100 g of rye flour, 100 g of water, and 20 g of active starter from the small final jar. Hold for 10–14 hours at 24–27 °C until domed with a lactic smell.

  4. Mix

    In the Kenwood stir the scald with 130 g of water — warm at 45–50 °C (dough about 27 °C, the plan is built around it) or at room temperature (dough about 23 °C, longer proof). Add the opara, 9 g of salt and 4 g of coriander, then 200 g of rye flour and 100 g of wheat flour. Mix with the K-beater on Min for 1–2 minutes to uniform.

  5. Transfer into the pan

    Grease the pan, transfer the dough, level with a wet spoon or wet fingers; mark the starting height and dough mass.

  6. Final proof

    Mark the starting height of the dough in the pan. Proof at room temperature, 22–23 °C, until a rise of 1.5–1.8 times with small cracks on the surface: 2–3 hours with warm mixing water, 3–4 hours with room-temperature water. Go by the rise, not by the timer.

  7. Bake

    250 °C 10 minutes with steam, 200 °C 30 minutes, 170 °C 30 minutes to the first probe check; if below 98 °C inside, top up in 5-minute increments.

  8. Rest

    Take out of the pan, cool on a rack uncovered, wrap in cotton/linen. Do not slice before 12 hours, better 24 hours.

A compact step map; notes and comments live in the worksheet.

R1-C4: working sheet · scald + malt

The sheet checks a rye-wheat 80/20 with a scald and red malt. Three refreshments bring the starter to peak, in the evening the scald and opara are built, in the morning comes the mix and bake, with the slice after 12+ hours.

Show the plan steps

  1. Day 1, 10:00–20:00

    Refreshment 1

    Take the rye starter out of the fridge. Mix 5 g of starter, 10 g of water, and 10 g of whole-grain rye flour. Base ratio for long cold storage: 1:2:2. Hold at room temperature, 22–24 °C; in a cool kitchen aim at the upper end of the window.

    Step ingredients

    • Starter 5 g of rye starter
    • Water 10 g
    • Whole-grain rye flour 10 g
    • Yield about 25 g
    Target
    The starter has woken up: there is rise and a clean smell with no sharp vinegar note.
    Check
    Record the exact time of the first refreshment for the journal export.
    Evidence
    Side photo of the jar, time, temperature next to the jar.

    10 h timer for this step

  2. Day 1–2, 20:00–08:00

    Refreshment 2

    When the first stage has given confident rise, bubbles, and a clean smell, do the second refreshment at 1:3:3. If the starter is not ready, wait for a clear peak.

    Step ingredients

    • Starter from refreshment 1 5 g
    • Water 15 g
    • Whole-grain rye flour 15 g
    • Yield about 35 g
    Target
    Confident rise after the first refreshment.
    Check
    Do not move on by the clock alone if the starter clearly has not come back to life.
    Evidence
    Time, temperature.

    12 h timer for this step

  3. Day 2, 08:00–18:00

    Refreshment 3

    When refreshment 2 has given a confident peak, do the small final refreshment at 5+20+20. If refreshment 2 has shifted, shift this step too.

    Step ingredients

    • Starter from refreshment 2 5 g
    • Water 20 g
    • Whole-grain rye flour 20 g
    • Yield about 45 g: 15–20 g reserve into the fridge, 20 g active starter into the opara, 5–10 g technical margin for jar losses
    Target
    Active rye starter at or near peak without a large excess jar.
    Check
    Before building the opara, first transfer 15–20 g of active starter into a clean jar and put it in the fridge; weigh out exactly 20 g for the opara.
    Evidence
    Time of peak, temperature.

    10 h timer for this step

  4. Day 2, 18:00–19:00

    Scald

    In a thermos or a jar with a tight lid, combine 100 g of whole-grain rye flour and 15 g of red fermented rye malt. Pour in 150 g of boiling water, stir quickly with no dry lumps, close tightly, and hold for 1 hour. Then simply leave it overnight until the morning mix — no reheating needed: in a 22–23 °C kitchen the scald cools by morning (barely warm in a thermos, room temperature in a jar), and the warm mixing water compensates for that.

    Step ingredients

    • Whole-grain rye flour 100 g
    • Red fermented rye malt 15 g
    • Water 150 g (boiling)
    • Yield about 265 g of thick dark scald
    Target
    Dark uniform sweet scald with no dry lumps; it may be at room temperature by mixing time — the warm mixing water accounts for that.
    Check
    The scald must not be hotter than 45 °C at mix time, otherwise opara acidity will suffer; a cold (room-temperature) scald is fine — the warm mixing water brings the dough up to temperature.
    Evidence
    Scald temperature, start/end times.

    1 h timer for this step

  5. Day 2–3, 18:00–08:00

    Sourdough opara

    Before building the opara, set aside 15–20 g of mature starter into a clean jar and put it in the fridge — this is the reserve mother starter for future bakes. 20 g from the small active jar goes into the opara. Mix 100 g of whole-grain rye flour, 100 g of water, and 20 g of active starter from small refreshment 3. Cover and hold at room temperature until domed with a lactic smell; in a 22–23 °C kitchen that is closer to 13–14 hours — almost the whole overnight window.

    Step ingredients

    • Whole-grain rye flour 100 g
    • Water 100 g
    • Active rye starter (from refreshment 3) 20 g from the remainder after the reserve
    • Yield about 220 g of sourdough opara
    Target
    Opara has risen 1.8–2.5 times, bubbles throughout the mass, a sour rye smell.
    Check
    Readiness is decided by the dome and a rise of 1.8–2.5 times, not by the clock: pulling it on a timer before the dome (say at 10 hours in a 22–23 °C kitchen) is usually early — the opara needs almost the whole 12–14 hour window. Pulling early costs rise. If the opara clearly over-matured and dropped sharply, you can still use it, but the crumb will be more sour.
    Evidence
    Time, temperature.

    14 h timer for this step

  6. Day 3, 08:00–08:05

    Mix

    Into the Kenwood bowl put all of the scald (about 265 g) and 130 g of water, and stir. Choose the water temperature (see the table “Mixing water temperature” in the body of the recipe): warm water at 45–50 °C brings the dough to about 27 °C and keeps the proof within 2–3 hours — the plan is built around it; room-temperature water gives a dough of about 23 °C and a proof of 3–4 hours. Warm water goes in with the scald first — the mixture becomes barely warm and safe for the opara. Add all of the opara (about 220 g), 9 g of salt, and 4 g of coriander, stir to uniform, then add 200 g of whole-grain rye flour, 83 g of strong white bread flour and 17 g of whole-grain wheat flour. Mix with the K-beater on Min for 1–2 minutes to full uniform.

    Step ingredients

    • Sourdough opara all, about 220 g
    • Scald all, about 265 g, cooled to 35–40 °C
    • Water 130 g
    • Whole-grain rye flour 200 g
    • Strong white bread flour 83 g
    • Whole-grain wheat flour 17 g
    • Salt 9 g
    • Ground coriander 4 g
    • Dough yield about 920 g
    Target
    Thick sticky porridge with no dry spots; dough temperature after mixing depends on the water chosen — about 27 °C with warm water (45–50 °C) or about 23 °C with room-temperature water (with components at 22–23 °C).
    Check
    Do not look for a gluten window. Never pour water hotter than 50 °C; stir warm water into the scald first, and only then add the opara. With room-temperature water the dough comes out at about 23 °C — that is a working mode, but then lead the proof by rise rather than by the clock (see the next step). If the scald is somehow still hot (above 45 °C), cool it before mixing, otherwise opara acidity will drop.
    Evidence
    Dough temperature after mixing, scald temperature at mix time, texture photo.

  7. Day 3, 08:05–08:10

    Transfer into the pan

    Grease the pan, transfer the dough, and level the top with a wet spoon or wet fingers.

    Step ingredients

    • Dough after mixing all of it, about 920 g
    • Pan grease thin layer, not part of the formula
    Target
    Even surface, clear starting height.
    Check
    Mark dough height in the pan and the dough mass.
    Evidence
    Side photo, height mark, mass.

  8. Day 3, 08:10–10:10

    Final proof

    Proof at room temperature, 22–23 °C, until a rise of 1.5–1.8 times. With warm mixing water (dough about 27 °C) that is 2–3 hours; with room-temperature water (dough about 23 °C) — 3–4 hours. The sugar of the scald speeds fermentation up, a cool kitchen slows it down.

    Step ingredients

    • Dough in the pan all of it, about 920 g
    • New ingredients none added
    Target
    Top slightly domes, small cracks or burst bubbles appear.
    Check
    Mark the starting height of the dough in the pan right after loading — then a rise of 1.5–1.8 times is visible objectively rather than by eye. Track state, not only time; readiness is a rise of 1.5–1.8 times plus small cracks on the surface, not a timer. The plan shows times for warm water (2–3 hours); with room-temperature water the proof takes 3–4 hours, and the whole bake shifts about an hour later. Towards the end of the proof turn the oven on to 250 °C in advance so it is fully heated by loading time.
    Evidence
    Kitchen temperature, height.

    2 h timer for this step

  9. Day 3, 10:10–10:20

    Oven 250 °C + steam

    Place the pan on the rack, apply the oven's built-in steam at the start. Bake 10 minutes at 250 °C.

    Step ingredients

    • Dough after the proof all of it in the pan
    • Steam water for steam; not part of the dough formula
    Target
    Starting heat and moist surface.
    Check
    When the timer rings: remove steam and drop to 200 °C.
    Evidence
    Timer, oven mode.

  10. Day 3, 10:20–10:50

    Oven 200 °C

    Bake 30 minutes at 200 °C without additional steam.

    Step ingredients

    • New ingredients none added
    Target
    Main heat-through of the loaf and setting the shape.
    Check
    When the timer rings: drop to 170 °C. If the surface darkens fast from the malt, cover with foil.
    Evidence
    Timer, crust state.

    30 min timer for this step

  11. Day 3, 10:50–11:20

    Oven 170 °C · first check

    After the switch to 170 °C, set the timer for 30 minutes. At the end of the timer, do the first probe check.

    Step ingredients

    • New ingredients none added
    Target
    Understand how much is left until 98 °C in the center of the crumb.
    Check
    If already 98 °C — move to removal. If less — add 5-minute increments.
    Evidence
    Probe and timer.

    30 min timer for this step

  12. Day 3, 11:20–11:25

    Top-up at 170 °C

    If after the first check it is below 98 °C inside, set the timer for 5 minutes and check again. Repeat to 98–99 °C.

    Step ingredients

    • New ingredients none added
    Target
    98–99 °C in the center of the crumb.
    Check
    If the top darkens faster than doneness, cover with foil.
    Evidence
    Probe, timer.

  13. Day 4, 07:00–19:00

    Slice

    Cool on a rack for 2–3 hours uncovered, then wrap in cotton/linen. Slice no earlier than 12 hours, better 24 hours.

    Step ingredients

    • Finished bread the whole loaf after rest
    • New ingredients none added
    Target
    Crumb moist, dense but not gummy; the knife does not stick; the sweetness of the scald and the acidity of the opara are visible.
    Check
    Describe sweetness, acidity, malt aroma, coriander, density. If an early slice is gummy, slice again after 24 hours.
    Evidence
    Tasting note.

    12 h timer for this step

Version history

Show version history
  • v1.3August 3, 2026
    Problem
    The formula called for first-grade wheat flour, which the author cannot buy: MukaMuka does not make one, so the “brand the author uses” note named a product that does not exist.
    Change
    The ingredient is split into what actually goes into the dough: 83 g of strong white bread flour (MukaMuka Artisan Superiore 13.5%, type 00) and 17 g of whole-grain wheat. The 5:1 ratio brings the ash up to the first-grade limit of GOST 26574-2017, table 2 — no more than 0.75% against 0.55% for the highest grade. Total flour, water, salt and every other ingredient are unchanged; only the baker's percentages of these two entries, the worksheet lines and the formula summary were recalculated.
    Result
    The recipe now lists flour that can actually be bought. A reader who has mill-made first-grade flour simply takes 100 g of it instead of this pair.
    Conclusion
    Not yet verified by baking: on calculated ash and strength the blend matches first-grade flour, but its bran particles are coarser than a mill grind. If the crumb turns out noticeably rougher, reduce the whole-grain share.
  • v1.2July 8, 2026
    Problem
    The first bake on v1.1 showed that the opara had been pulled early (10 hours instead of the 12–14 hour window), the top crust cracked and tore away from the crumb, and the taste was thin (4/10). The wording of the steps did not stop the baker from pulling the opara and the proof “by the clock”.
    Change
    The check and target of the opara and proof steps, and the short instructions, were strengthened: pull the opara by the dome and a rise of 1.8–2.5 times (not by a timer; 10 hours at 22–23 °C is early, the window is 12–14 hours), and lead the proof to 1.5–1.8 times plus small cracks, marking the starting height in the pan.
    Result
    First bake 08.07.2026: the crumb was fully baked (probe 98.1 °C), even, not gummy; the link between the sweetness of the scald and the acidity of the opara came through moderately; the taste was acceptable but thin and weakly aromatic — the author scored it 4/10. The top crust cracked and lifted off the crumb.
    Conclusion
    The 4/10 was scored on an early-pulled opara, so it is not a clean verdict on the formula. Next step: repeat with the opara taken to a full dome (12–14 hours) and a complete proof; only after a clean data point decide about strengthening the taste (20–25 g of malt, or a 2-hour scald per the research section).
Development history (2)

Intermediate theoretical notes before the first bake.

  • v1.1July 6, 2026in development
    Problem
    The author's kitchen holds 22–23 °C, while the v1.0 plan assumed 24–28 °C and required reheating the cooled scald to 35–40 °C in a water bath.
    Change
    After its hour in the thermos the scald now stays overnight without reheating; its room temperature is compensated by the mixing water. The water is a choice: warm at 45–50 °C (dough about 27 °C, the plan is built around it — proof 2–3 hours), or room temperature (dough about 23 °C — proof 3–4 hours). The opara is led to a dome rather than to a fixed number of hours.
    Conclusion
    To be checked by the first bake: does the dough reach 26–29 °C with water at 45–50 °C, and does the opara ripen within the overnight window at 22–23 °C.
  • v1.0May 25, 2026in development
    Problem
    In the R1-C rye track, after R1-C3 (100% rye), a transition to a rye with a scald and malt is needed — without the sweetness of molasses/sugar and without the complexity of caraway, as a bridge to R2-C1 (Borodinsky).
    Change
    Created R1-C4: rye-wheat 80/20 with a scald (100 g rye + 150 g boiling water + 15 g red malt), a sourdough opara with 20% of the flour preferred, and optional coriander.
    Conclusion
    The lesson tests how the sweetness of the scald contrasts with the acidity of the opara and whether this gives a recognizable profile without adding molasses and sugar.